The Hidden Handshake — How Silent Agreements Shape Your Workplace

You walk into your first meeting at a new job. No one told you where to sit, but everyone somehow knows. The boss makes a comment that no one challenges, and you notice people exchange glances but say nothing. You stay quiet too. Welcome to the workplace rulebook that no one handed you: silent agreements.

What Are Silent Agreements?

Silent agreements are the unspoken rules that govern how people behave in organizations. These aren’t the policies written in the HR handbook or announced in company-wide emails. They’re the norms and expectations people absorb over time—like "don’t microwave fish in the office kitchen" or "no one leaves before the boss does."

They show up in everything from meeting dynamics (who speaks and who stays quiet) to decision-making, promotions, and even how feedback is given. And because they live in the shadows of official policy, they often shape our day-to-day work experiences more than anything on paper.

The Good, the Bad, and the Awkward

Not all silent agreements are bad. Some can create a sense of shared culture and smooth collaboration. For example:

• The first person in turns on the coffee machine.

• Senior staff mentor junior staff without being told to.

• Brainstorm sessions are understood to be judgment-free zones.

These kinds of unspoken norms can be helpful—they provide consistency, efficiency, and even a sense of belonging.

But here’s the flip side: when left unchecked, silent agreements can reinforce outdated behaviors, discourage innovation, and contribute to toxic work environments. Consider these examples:

• An unwritten rule that it's career suicide to challenge leadership.

• A culture where taking lunch is seen as slacking off.

• A team dynamic where only certain people get "real" assignments while others are quietly sidelined.

These silent expectations might have started as coping mechanisms or informal habits, but over time, they can solidify into cultural barriers.

How Do They Form?

Silent agreements often begin as responses to real situations. Maybe one employee stayed late and got praise, so others started staying late too. Or someone asked for help and got reprimanded, so everyone else learned to suffer in silence. Multiply that over weeks, months, or years—and suddenly, you’ve got a culture based on fear or assumption rather than communication.

In many workplaces, silent agreements are reinforced by hierarchy, cultural norms, or a simple lack of psychological safety. If people don’t feel they can speak up or ask questions, they’ll observe and adapt instead. That might keep the peace temporarily, but it also keeps people from bringing their full selves to work.

Why They Matter

Silent agreements matter because they often define the real workplace culture. And when those unspoken rules are misaligned with your values, your DEI goals, or your business strategy, they can quietly sabotage progress.

They can:

• Erode trust and communication

• Promote burnout and disengagement

• Undermine official policies and leadership intentions

• Disadvantage employees who are new, underrepresented, or outside the dominant culture

You can have a mission statement that screams innovation, but if the silent agreement is "don’t question the process," your culture isn’t living up to it.

What Leaders and Teams Can Do

Here’s the good news: once you can see silent agreements, you can start to change them.

1. Talk About the Unspoken. During team meetings or retreats, ask: "What are the unspoken rules here?" You might be surprised at what surfaces.

2. Model Transparency. Leaders can break the cycle by naming their expectations and encouraging healthy challenge.

3. Create Psychological Safety. Teams thrive when people feel safe to ask questions, admit mistakes, or offer new ideas.

4. Challenge the Status Quo. Just because "we’ve always done it this way" doesn’t mean it’s still working. Make it a habit to re-evaluate your team’s norms.

   
   

Final Thought

Think of silent agreements as the workplace’s secret operating system. They might be invisible, but they’re powerful. When you bring them into the light, you give your team a chance to grow beyond assumptions and into intentional, equitable, and empowering ways of working.

So the next time something feels "off" at work but no one can quite name it, ask yourself: What’s the silent agreement here? And is it time to renegotiate?

Want to explore more unspoken dynamics in your workplace? Subscribe to The Resolution Room podcast, where we turn hidden habits into actionable insights. Available on all major platforms.

Join my mailing list for more insights, tools, and exclusive content on leadership and workplace dynamics. And if you're ready to dive deeper, check out my book Human Resources for the Soul — now available on Amazon: https://a.co/d/fiLI7xE.